The Abortion in Soviet Russia During NEP: Official Propaganda versus Popular Attitudes
https://doi.org/10.22394/2073-7203-2020-38-4-229-264
EDN: IRAABK
Abstract
This paper studies the attitudes of the Soviet authorities and society towards the problem of abortion during the New Economic Policy (NEP). In the 1920s, communist ideologists and population still under influence of traditional values based on religious ethics (though often indifferent towards religion and Church) expressed extremely different views on the issue. Even religiously indifferent people used to take part in religious ceremonies such as weddings and christenings. The traditions of the Orthodox Church provided them with moral support in the era of global changes. The ideological message of the Soviet authorities was also controversial. Officially sexual liberty was allowed, as was the freedom of marriage and divorce. Women were encouraged to work, to be involved in social activities, to be educated. However, there was little social and medical help for mothers. Traditional marriage was being destroyed, and an increasing number of abortions, both legal and illegal, was a result. Those who were in charge of the sanitary propaganda were worried and encouraged people to have children for Soviet Russia instead of abortions despite all difficulties. In fact, ordinary people knew that many children meant poverty and poor health for the whole family. There was almost no available contraception, and abortion was virtually only method of birth control. In spite of the efforts of Soviet propaganda, abortion was perceived as a nasty but almost unavoidable part of everyday life. The author concludes that no consensus on the problem of abortion in the Soviet society of the 1920s emerged, and to some extent it could not have emerged under such circumstances.
About the Author
Maria Grafova
National Research University Higher School of Economics
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Faculty of World Economy and International Affairs
References
1. Aborty v 1925 godu (1927) [Abortion in 1925]. Moscow: Izdanie T͡SSU SSSR.
2. Aborty v 1926 godu (1929) [Abortion in 1926]. Moscow: Stat. Izd-vo T͡SSU SSSR.
3. Akimov, G. (1926) Semʹ Zhen Ivana Gruznogo ili Delo ob Alimentakh [Ivan Gruznyj’s Seven Wifes or Alimony Claim]. Moscow: Moskovskoe Teatralʹnoe Izdatelʹstvo.
4. Altrichter, H. (1991) “Insoluble Conflicts: Village Life between Revolution and Collectivization”, in Sh. Fitzpatrick, A. Rabinovitch, and R. Stites (eds.) Russia in the Era of the NEP. Explorations in Soviet Society and Culture, pp. 192–210. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press.
5. Avdeev, A. Blum, A., Troitskaya, I. (1995) “The History of Abortion Statistics in Russia and the USSR from 1900 to 1991”, Population: An English Selection 7: 39–66.
6. Balagin, A. (1928). “Svadʹba Chekhova” [Chekhov’s Wedding], in Sovetskii vodevilʹ. Sbornik 6. pp. 3–22. Moscow-Leningrad: MODPIK.
7. Beliakova, E. (2004) Tserkovnyi sud [Ecclesiastical Court]. Moscow: NPKTS “Dukhovnaia biblioteka”.
8. Beliakova, E., Beliakova N., Emchenko E. (2011) Zhenshchina v pravoslavii. Tserkovnoe pravo i rossiiskaia politika [Woman in Orthodox Church. Canon Law and Russian Politics]. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole.
9. Bozhinskaia, N. (1927) Prestuplenie Ivana Kuznetsova [Ivan Kuznetsov’s Crime]. Moscow: Molodaia Gvardiia.
10. Bozhinskaia, N. (1927) Svobodnaia liubovʹ [Free Love]. Moscow-Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelʹstvo.
11. Braude, I. (1929) V ugolovnom sude. Iz zapisok zashchitnika 1922–1928 [In Criminal Court: Notes of an Attorney 1922–1928]. Second Edition. Хarʹkov.: Iuridicheskoe izdatelʹstvo narkomiusta USSR.
12. Bukharenkova, O. (2013) Sovetskaia politika likvidatsii bezrabotitsy v 1921–27 godakh. [Soviet Politics of the Elimination of Unemployment in 1921–1927]. Moscow: Redaktsionno-izdatelʹskii otdel MGOGI.
13. Dadʹiants, N. (1927) Iski ob alimentakh. Vzyskanie v sudebnom poriadke na soderzhanie detei, rodstvennikov i suprugov [Guidebook: How to Claim Alimony]. Moscow: Pravo i zhiznʹ.
14. Demidovich, E. (1927) Sud nad polovoi raspushchennostʹiu. [Trial over Sexual Promiscuity]. Moscow-Leningrad: Doloi negramotnostʹ.
15. Demograficheskaia modernizatsiia Rossii, 1900–2000 (2006) [Demographic Modernization in Russia, 1900–2000)]. Ed. Vishnevskii A. Moscow: Novoe Izdatelstvo.
16. Dorokhina, O. (2019) “Semʹia i Novaia ekonomicheskaia politika (NEP): ėksperiment protiv traditsii” [Family and New Economic Policy: Experiment versus Tradition], Ėkonomika i predprinimatelʹstvo, 5: 87–91.
17. Durkheim, E. (1991) O razdelenii obshchestvennogo truda [The Division of Labour in Society]. Moscow: Nauka.
18. Durkheim, E. (1998) Samoubiistvo. Sotsiologicheskii ėtiud [Suicide: A Study in Sociology]. S.-P.: Soiuz.
19. Egorysheva, I. (2015) “Okhrana materinstva i mladenchestva v pervye gody deiatelʹnosti narodnogo komissariata zdravookhraneniia RSFSR” [Motherhood and Infancy Care in the First Years Activity of the RSFSR People’s Commissariat of Health], Biulletenʹ natsionalʹnogo nauchno-issledovatelʹskogo instituta obshchestvennogo zdorovʹia imeni N.A.Semashko 7: 29–36.
20. Freeze, G. L. (2009) “Mirskie narrativy o sviashchennom tainstve: Brak i razvod v pozdneimperskoi Rossii” [Secular Narratives on the Subject of Sacred Sacrament: Marriage and Divorce in Later Russian Empire], in Dolbilov, M., Kolonitskii, B. and Rogoznyi, P. (eds.) Pravoslavie: konfessiia, instituty, religioznost’ (XVII-XX vv.), pp. 122–175. St. Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo Evropeiskogo universiteta v S. Peterburge.
21. Freeze, G. (2019). «Votserkovlenie» 1917 goda: tserkovnyi krizis i prikhodskaia revoliutsiia [“Churching” 1917: The Church Crisis and the Parish Revolution], Gosudarstvo, religiia, tserkovʹ v Rossii i za rubezhom 1–2: 30–57.
22. Freeze, G. (2012) “Vsia vlastʹ prikhodam”: vozrozhdenie pravoslaviia v 1920-e gg. [All Power to The Parishes: Revival of The Orthodox Church in 1920s], Gosudarstvo, religiia, tserkovʹ v Rossii i za rubezhom 3–4: 86–105.
23. Gelʹman, I. (1923) Polovaia zhiznʹ sovremennoi molodezhi [Sex Life of the Today’s Youth]. Moscow-Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelʹstvo.
24. Gens, A. (1925). Abort v RSFSR. [Abortion in Russian Federation]. Moscow: Izdatelʹstvo “Okhrana materinstva i mladenchestva”.
25. Gofmekler, A. (1927) Abort [Abortion]. Moscow: Okhrana materinstva i mladenchestva.
26. Goldman, W. (1993) Women, the State and Revolution: Soviet Family Policy and Social Life, 1917–1936. New-York: Cambridge University Press.
27. Grigorovich, N. Fabrichnaia liubovʹ [Love Story of Factory Workers]. Moscow: MODPiK, 1925.
28. Gross Solomon, S. (1992) “The Demographic Argument in Soviet Debates over the Legalization of Abortion in the 1920’s”, Cahiers du Monde russe et soviétique 33(Jan.-Mar. No 1): 59–81.
29. Kanevskii, A. (1925) Sud nad Annoi Gorbovoi po obvineniiu v proizvodstve sebe vykidy‑ sha (aborta) [Trial of Anna Gorbova for Illegal Abortion]. Odessa: Odesskii dom Sanprosveta.
30. Ketlinskaia, V., Slepkov, V. (1929) Zhiznʹ bez kontrolia (polovaia zhiznʹ i semʹia rabochei molodezhi) [Life without Control (Sex Life аnd Family of Young Workers)]. M-L: Molodaia Gvardiia.
31. Khalfin, V. (1927) “Istreblenie ploda (abort) v Moskve i Moskovskoi gubernii” [Abortion in Moscow and Moscow Region], in Problemy prestupnosti. Sbornik. V. 2., pp. 190–211. Moscow-Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelʹstvo
32. Kirillova, D. (2005) Rozhdaemostʹ v SSSR v 1930-e gody. Gosudarstvennai͡a politika. Statistika (po materialam tekushchego ucheta T͡SUNХU SSSR) [Birth Rate in the USSR in 30s. Government Policies and Statistics]. Moscow: izd-vo T͡SGL RON.
33. Kostitsyn, A. (1929) Trudiashchaiasia zhenshchina i religiia [Working Woman and Religion]. M.-L: Moskovskii rabochii.
34. Lebedeva, V. (1923) “Samoistreblenie chelovechestva” [Self-Destruction of Humankind], Kommunistka 9: 3–5.
35. Lebina, N. (2007) «Navstrechu mnogochislennym pozhelaniiam trudiashchikhsia zhen‑ shchin…». Abortnaia politika kak zerkalo sovetskoi sotsialʹnoi zaboty [“Towards Many Appeals of Working Women…” Abortion Politics as a Mirror of Soviet Social Care], in Romanov P., Iarskaia-Smirnova E. (eds.) Sovetskaia sotsialʹnaia politika 1920–1930-kh godov: ideologiia i povsednevnostʹ [Soviet Social Policy in 1920–1930s: Ideology and Everyday Life], pp. 228–241. Moscow: Variant CSPGS.
36. Lebina, N. (1999) Povsednevnaia zhiznʹ sovetskogo goroda: normy i anomalii 1920–1930‑ e gody [Daily Life of a Soviet City: Norms and Anomalies. 1920–1930-s]. Sankt-Peterburg: Letnii sad.
37. Lenin, V. (1913) Rabochii klass i neomalʹtuzianstvo [Working Class and Neomalthusian‑ ism]. Complete Works. Vol. 23. P. 255–257.
38. Levi, M. (1927) Protivozachatochnye sredstva [Contraception]. Moscow: Moszdravotdel.
39. Lin, I. (1925) Iacheikina dochʹ [Komsomol’s Daughter]. Moscow-Leningrad: Molodaia gvardiia.
40. Luchshev, E. (2016) Antireligioznaia propaganda v SSSR 1917–1941 [Antireligious Propaganda in the USSR in 1917–1941]. S.-P.: Gosudarstvennyi muzei istorii religii.
41. Manns, G. (1927) Abort kak sotsialʹnoe iavlenie i problema ego nakazuemosti [Abortion as a Social Phenomenon and the Problem of its Punishability]. Хarʹkov: Iuridicheskoe izdatelʹstvo NKIU USSR.
42. Merton, R. K. (2006) “Sotsialʹnaia struktura i anomiia” [Social Structure and Anomie], in Sotsialʹnaia teoriia i sotsialʹnaia struktura [Social Theory and Social Structure], pp. 243–281. Moscow: Хranitelʹ.
43. Miroshnichenko, I. Styazhkina, H. (2012) “Abortnaia politika v SSSR v 20–30-e gody: is‑ toriografiia voprosa” (Abortion Politics in the USSR in 1920–30-th years: Historiography of a Question), Visnik Mariupolʹskogo derzhavnogo universiteta. Seriia: Istoriia. Politologiia, 3: 43–50.
44. Ognev, N. (1927) Dnevnik Kosti Riabtseva [Kostia Riabtsev’s Diary]. Moscow-Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelʹstvo.
45. Ognev, N. (1925) “Manʹka Guzikova”, Komsomolʹskaia pravda. 22.09.1925. P. 3.
46. Okinchits, L. (1924) Vykidysh i predokhranitelʹnye sredstva ot beremennosti [Abortion and Contraception]. Leningrad: Meditsina.
47. Pivovarov, N. Shok, N. (2019) “K istorii zapreta abortov v SSSR: pozitsiia vlastei i mneni‑ ia sovetskogo obshchestva v bioėticheskom rakurse” [On the history of the ban of the abortion in the USSR: the views of the authorities and Soviet public opinion from the perspective of bioethics (1935–1936)], Istoriia meditsiny 6 (2): 118–126.
48. Problema pola [Gender Problem] (1926), Zhenskii Zhurnal 2(4).
49. Protoklitov, S. (1926) Doloi babku! [Down with the Traditional Helper!]. Moscow: Okhra‑ na materinstva i mladenchestva.
50. Pushkarev, A., Pushkareva, N. (2007) „Ranniaia sovetskaia ideologiia 1918–1928 i «polo‑ voi vopros» (o popytkakh uregulirovaniia sotsialʹnoi politiki v oblasti seksualʹnosti)“ [Early Soviet Ideology of the 1918–1928 and “sexual question” (Attempts to Regulate Social Policy in Sphere of Sexuality)], in Romanov P., Iarskaia-Smirnova E. (eds.) Sovetskaia sotsialʹnaia politika 1920–1930-kh godov: ideologiia i povsednevnostʹ [Soviet Social Policy in 1920–1930s: Ideology and Everyday Life], pp. 199–227. Moscow: Variant CSPGS.
51. Rivkin, A. (1922) Sovremennyi vzgliad na abort-vykidysh [Contemporary view on abortion- miscarriage]. Orsha.
52. Semashko, N. (1927) Protiv alimentnoi ėpidemii, ili na alimenty nadeisia, a sam ne ploshai [Against Alimony Epidemic]. Moscow: Okhrana materinstva i mladenchestva.
53. Severʹianov, M. Anisimova L. (2013) “Abort kak sredstvo planirovaniia semʹi v Rossii per‑ voi chetverti XX v. [Abortion as a Means of Family Planning in Russia in the First Quarter of the Twentieth Century], Zhurnal Sibirskogo federalʹnogo universiteta. Seriia: Gumanitarnye nauki 6(7): 1066–1074.
54. Smidovich, S. (1927) “O korenʹkovshchine” [Koren’kov’s Syndrom], in Razin I. (ed.) Komsomolʹskii byt [Daily Life of Komsomol], pp. 132–140. Moscow-Leningrad: Molodaia Gvardiia.
55. Sobranie uzakonenii i rasporiazhenii pravitelʹstva za 1920 god [Body of Law of Russian Federation in 1920] Moscow, 1943.
56. Stenograficheskii otchet zasedanii 2 sessii Vserossiiskogo tsentralʹnogo ispolnitelʹnogo komiteta XII sozyva 17 i 19 oktiabria 1925 goda po proektu kodeksa zakonov o brake, semʹe i opeke [Verbatim Record of a Committee Meeting about the Project of the New Family Code], in Kurskii D. (ed.) Sbornik statei i materialov po brachnomu i semeinomu pravu [Book on Family Law], pp. 107–194. Moscow: Iuridicheskoe izdatelʹstvo N.K.Iu R.S.F.S.R.
57. Shchelkanova, M. (1926) Riadovye [Ordinary Soldiers]. Moscow-Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelʹstvo.
58. Stoianovskaia, Ė.L. (1913) 12-i Pirogovskii S”ezd. Otdel akusherstva i zhenskikh boleznei. 2-e zasedanie 1.07 [12th Medical Conference of Gynecologists and Obstetricians, Second Meeting 1.07.1913], Russkii vrach 28: 1010–1012.
59. Uzhanskii, G. (1926) Ob onanizmu [Onanism]. Saratov.
60. Vetrov, B., Petrov L. (1926). Agitsud i zhivaia gazeta v derevne [Propaganda Trials and Amateur Theatre in the Countryside]. Moscow-Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe Izdatelʹstvo.
61. Volʹpert, I. (1926) Zhivaia gazeta (materialy dlia vecherov sanitarnogo prosveshcheniia) [Amateur Theatre for Sanitary Propaganda]. Issue 1. Leningrad: Sanprosvet Leningradskogo Gubzdravotdela.
Review
For citations:
Grafova M. The Abortion in Soviet Russia During NEP: Official Propaganda versus Popular Attitudes. State, Religion and Church in Russia and Worldwide. 2020;38(4):229-264. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22394/2073-7203-2020-38-4-229-264. EDN: IRAABK
Views:
1
Email this article 