“They Will Fall in the Unearthly Grandeur”: The Early Soviet Cult of Martyrs of the Revolution
https://doi.org/10.22394/2073-7203-2022-40-1-58-88
Abstract
The secular cult of the fallen heroes — martyrs of the revolution became the most important component of the Bolshevik historical mythology of the early Soviet period (1917–1920s). This cult clearly showed a religious origin and a number of differences from the cult of heroes of the later Soviet era. The early revolutionary martyrdom, from February 1917 and the first months after October 1917, developed as a collective and largely anonymous, symbolic phenomenon. These features were also evident in the early martyriums, the mass graves on the Field of Mars in Petrograd and near the Kremlin Wall in Moscow. However, the Bolsheviks’ creation of their own, revolutionary secular pantheon based on religious models later individualized martyrdom and developed its special criteria. A sign of individualization was the compilation of martyrologies and the formation of practices of veneration of martyrs’ burial places. The cult of martyrs acquired an international character through inclusion in the pantheon of the victims of revolutionary events in Europe. The discursive tropes formed to describe heroic martyrdom initially normalized only violent death at the hands of the enemy. After the end of the Civil War, however, the emerging linguistic ritualization allowed for the heroization of the circumstances of death: those who died of illness, accidents, even suicides were counted as martyrs. Gradually the number of heroes was reduced while the range of their types was, on the contrary, expanded. The martyr hero took an increasingly modest place in the hierarchy of heroes, the tropes of describing martyrdom were simplified and standardized, and their biographies were straightened and taken on a symbolic rather than an individual form.
About the Author
S. Malysheva
Kazan (Volga Region) Federal University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Svetlana Malysheva — Professor
Kazan
References
1. Andreeva, L. A. (2018) “Sekuliarnaia sviatost’: kul’t revoliutsionnykh muchenikov v rossiiskoi istorii” [“Secular sanctity: cult of revolutionary martyrs in Russian history”], Dialog so vremenem 64: 278–295.
2. Aron, R. (2015) Opium intellektualov [The Opium of the Intellectuals]. M.: Izdatel’stvo AST.
3. Behrenbeck, S. (1996) Der Kult um die toten Helden. Nationalsozialistische Mythen, Riten und Symbole 1923 bis 1945. Vierow bei Greifswald: SH-Verlag.
4. Bellah, R. N. (1967) “Civil Religion in America”, Dædalus 96(1): 1–21.
5. “Biografiia tov. Uritskogo (K godovshchine so dnia smerti)” [“Biography of Comrade Uritsky (on the Anniversary of His Death)”] (1919), Kommunisticheskii Internatsional, 4: 547–550.
6. Bodriiar, Zh. (2011) Simvolicheskii obmen i smert’ [A Symbolic Exchange and Death]. M.: “Dobrosvet”, “Izdatel’stvo “KDU””.
7. Bogdanov, A. A. (1920) “Ocherki organizatsionnoi nauki. Raskhozhdenie i skhozhdenie form” [“Essays on Organizational Science. The Divergence and Convergence of Forms”], Proletarskaia kul’tura 15–16: 6–38.
8. Bohmann, G. (2009) “Politische Religionen“ (Eric Voegelin und Raymond Aron) — ein Begriff zur Differenzierung von Fundamentalismen?”, Österreichische Zeitschrift für Soziologie 34(1): 3–22.
9. Bratskaia mogila: biograficheskii slovar’ umershikh i pogibshikh chlenov Moskovskoi organizatsii RKP [Brothers’ Grave: Biographical Index of the Dead and Deceased Members of the Moscow Organization of the Russian Communist Party], Vyp. 1–2 (1922–1923). M.: Moskovskii rabochii.
10. Bukharin, N. (1919) “Tibor Samueli” [Tibor Samueli], Kommunisticheskii Internatsional 5: 711–712.
11. Chertilina, M. I. (2011) “Pokhorony zhertv Fevral’skoi revoliutsii v Petrograde 23 marta 1917 g. v kinofotodokumentakh RGAKFD” [“Funeral of victims of the February Revolution in Petrograd on March 23, 1917 in film and photo documents of the Russian State Archive of Film and Photo Documents”], Otechestvennye arkhivy 1: 45–51.
12. Clark, K. (1995) Petersburg, Cruisible of Cultural Revolution. London; Cambridge (Mass.): Harvard University Press.
13. Dzhentile, E. (2021) Politicheskie religii. Mezhdu demokratiei i totalitarismom [Political Religions. Between Democracy and Totalitarianism]. SPb.: Vladimir Dal’ [https://tinyurl.com/2p9b9ubf, accessed on 19.02.2022].
14. Figes, O., Kolonitskii, B. (1999) Interpreting the Russian Revolution. The Language and Symbols of 1917. New Haven; London: Yale University Press.
15. Fridlender, K. (1999) “Neskol’ko aspektov shellshock’а v Rossii 1914–1916” [Several Aspects of Shellshock in Russia 1914–1916], in Rossiia i Pervaia mirivaia voina (Materialy mezhdunarodnogo nauchnogo kollokwiuma, pp. 315–325. SPb.: Dmitrii Bulanin.
16. Geldern, von J. (1993) Bolshevik Festivals, 1917–1920. Berkeley, London: University of California Press.
17. Gentile, E., Mallett, R. (2000) “The Sacralisation of Politics: Definitions, Interpretations and Reflections on the Question of Secular Religion and Totalitarianism”, Totalitarian Movements and Political Religions 1(1): 18–55.
18. Giunter, Kh. (2000) “Arkhetipy sovetskoi kul’tury” [Archetypes of Soviet Culture], in Kh. Giunter. E. Dobrenko (red.) Sotsrealisticheskii kanon, pp. 743–784. Spb.: Akademicheskii proekt.
19. Halfin, I. (2000) From Darkness to Light. Class, Conscionsness and Salvation in Revolutionary Russia. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
20. Herz, D. (1996) “Der Begriff der „politischen Religionen“ im Denken Eric Voegelins”, in H. Maier (hrsg.) Totalitarismus und Politische Religionen. Konzepte des Diktaturvergleichs, ss. 191–209. Paderborn u.a.: Schöningh.
21. Hildebrandt, M. (2005) “Einleitung: Unfriedliche Religionen? Das politische Gewaltund Konfliktpotenzial von Religionen”, in M. Hildebrandt, M. Brocker (hrsg.) Unfriedliche Religionen? Das politische Gewalt — und Konfliktpotenzial von Religionen, ss. 9–35. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
22. K. V. I. (1919) “Pamiati Evgeniia Levine” [In Memory of Eugen Levine], Kommunisticheskii Internatsional 6: 925–926.
23. “Kak palachi Noske raspravlialis’ s proletarskoi revoliutsiei. Neopublikovannye snimki s trupa Karla Libknekhta” [How Noske’s executioners massacred the proletarian revolution. Unpublished photos of Karl Liebknecht’s cadaver] (1925), Kommunisticheskii Internatsional 4(41): 70–71.
24. Kolarov, V. (1924) “U mogily tov. Lenina” [At the tomb of Comrade Lenin], Pravda, January 24.
25. Lezhava, L., Rusakov, G. (eds.) (1925) Pamiatnik bortsam proletarskoi revoliutsii, pogibshim v 1917–1921 gg. [biograficheskii spravochnik] [Monument to fighters of the proletarian revolution, who died in 1917–1921 [biographical guide]. M.-L: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo.
26. [M.] (1919) “V. Volodarskii (1891–1918)” [V. Volodarskii (1891–1918)], Kommunisticheskii Internatsional, 3: 349–352.
27. Maier, H. (1995) “Totalitarismus” und “Politische Religionen“. Konzepte des Diktaturvergleichs“, Vierteljahrshefte für Zeitgeschichte 43(3): 387–405.
28. Malysheva, S. (2015) “Helden oder Blutopfer: Der Umgang der Zeitgenossen mit den Gefallenen des Ersten Weltkriegs in Russland” [“Heroes or Victims of a “Bloody Tribute”? How Contemporaries Viewed at the Dead of the First World War and Rationalised their Death”], Jahrbücher für Geschichte Osteuropas 63(4): 599–618.
29. Malysheva, S. Iu. (2019) “Na miru krasna”: instrumentalizatsiia smerti v Sovetskoi Rossii [“Is Good among People”: The Instrumentalization of Death in Soviet Russia]. M.: Novyi khronograf.
30. Malysheva, S. Iu. (2005) Sovetskaia prazdnichnaia kul’tura v provintsii: prostranstvo, simvoly, istoricheskie mify (1917–1927) [Soviet Festival Culture in the Province: Space, Symbols, and Historical Myths (1917-1927)]. Kazan’: Ruten.
31. Meilitsev, G., Sidorova, I. (1973) “Gavrosh Krasnogo Petrograda”, in I. I. Slobozhan (ed.) Belye nochi: ocherki, zarisovki, dokumenty, vospominaniia [“The Gavroche of Red Petrograd”, in I. I. Slobozhan (ed.) White Nights: Essays, Sketches, Documents, Memoirs], pp. 285–319. L: Lenizdat.
32. Milkich, I. (1920) “Dimitrii Tutsuvich (1881–1914)” [Dimitrii Tutsuvich (1881–1914)], Kommunisticheskii Internatsional, 14: 2984–2986.
33. Minkova, Ju. (2018) Making Martyrs: The Language of Sacrifice in Russian Culture from Stalin to Putin. Rochester, NY: University of Rochester Press.
34. Mogil’ner, M. B. (1999) Mifologiia “podpol’nogo cheloveka”: radikal’nyi mikrokosm v Rossii nachala XX veka kak predmet semioticheskogo analiza [Mythology of the “Underground Man”: Radical Microcosm in Early 20th Century Russia as a Subject of Semiotic Analysis]. M: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie.
35. Morgan, K. (2017) International Communism and the Cult of the Individual: Leaders, Tribunes and Martyrs under Lenin and Stalin. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
36. Moroz, E. V. (2012) “Religiozno-kriticheskaia kontseptsiia totalitarisma v zarubezhnoi istoriografii 30-kh godov XX veka” [The Religious-Critical Concept of Totalitarianism in Foreign Historiography in the 1930s], Vestnik Kemerovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta 4-1(52): 88–94.
37. “Nashi mertvetsy. Karl Libknekht” [Our Dead. Karl Liebknecht] (1919), Kommunisticheskii Internatsional, 1: between 80–81.
38. Pamiatnik bortsam proletarskoi revoliutsii, pogibshim v 1917–1921 gg. Vyp. 1 [Monument to fighters of the proletarian revolution, who died in 1917–1921. Issue 1] (1922). M.: Gosizdat.
39. Pinnow, K. M. (2010) Lost to the Collective: Suicide and the Promise of Soviet Socialism, 1921–1929. Ithaca, London: Cornell University Press.
40. Pravila N 198/B/197/mb Narodnogo komissariata vnutrennikh del i Narodnogo komissariata zdravookhraneniia “Ob ustroistve kladbishch i poriadke pogrebeniia” 7/11 iiunia 1929 g. [Regulations N 198/B/197/mb of the People’s Commissariat of Internal Affairs and the People’s Commissariat of Health “On the arrangement of cemeteries and the order of burial” 7/11 June 1929] (1929), Biulleten’ Narodnogo komissariata vnutrennikh del 23–24: 458–462.
41. Rafes, M., Model’, M., Iablon’skii, A. (eds.) (1924) U velikoi mogily. Moscow: Izdanie gazety “Krasnaia Zvezda”.
42. Schechter, R. (2014) “Terror, Vengeance, and Martyrdom in the French Revolution”, in Janes D., Houen A. (eds) Martyrdom and Terrorism: Pre-Modern to Contemporary Perspectives, pp. 152–178. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
43. Schwendimann, U. (2000) “Der Tod als Ode an das System. Textsortenmutationen als Bestandteil verbaler Propaganda — am Beispiel von Texten über den Tod”, in D. Weiss (hrsg.) Der Tod in der Propaganda: (Sowjetunion und Volksrepublik Polen), ss. 1–12. Bern: Peter Lang.
44. Shigaev (1924) “Gibel’ shestnadtsati” [The deaths of sixteen], Krasnaia Tatariia, June 28.
45. Slavianova, Z. M. (1922) Pamiati Parizhskoi Kommuny. Instsenirovka istoricheskikh sobytii, lits, rechei parizhskikh kommunarov 71 goda [In Memory of the Paris Commune. Staging of historical events, faces, speeches of the Paris Commune of 71]. Kazan‘.
46. Smirnova, A. A. (2016) “Natsional’nye pokhorony zhertv Fevral’skoi revoliutsii i deiateli russkoi kul’tury” [National Funeral for the Victims of the February Revolution and Russian Cultural Figures], Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo gosudarstvennogo instituta kul’tury i iskusstv 4(29): 27–32.
47. Steinberg, M. D. (2007) “A Path of Thorns”: The Spiritual Wounds and Wandering of Worker-Poets”, in M. D. Steinberg, H. J. Coleman (eds) Sacred Stories: Religion and Spirituality in Modern Russia (Indiana-Michigan Series in Russian and East European Studies), pp. 304–329. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
48. Steinberg, M. D. (2002) Proletarian Imagination: Self, Modernity, and the Sacred in Russia, 1910–1925. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
49. Steindorff, L. (1994) Memoria in Altrussland: Untersuchungen zu den Formen christlicher Totensorge. Stuttgart: Steiner.
50. Steklov, Iu. (1919) “U svezhei mogily” [At the fresh grave], Izvestiia VTsIK Sovetov 59(611): 1.
51. Stites, R. (1989) Revolutionary Dreams. Utopian Vision and Experimental Life on the Russian Revolution. New York; Oxford: Oxford University Press.
52. “Tov. Tibor Samueli” [Comrade Tibor Szamuely] (1919), Kommunisticheskii Internatsional 7–8: between 1128–1129.
53. Tumarkin, N. (1997) Lenin zhiv! Kul’t Lenina v Sovetskoi Rossii [Lenin Lives! The Lenin Cult in Soviet Russia]. Sankt-Petersburg: Akademicheskii proekt.
54. Voegelin, E. (1993) Die politischen Religionen. Muenchen: Fink.
55. Vondung, K. (1971) Magie und Manipulation. Ideologischer Kult und politische Religion des Nationalsozialismus. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
56. Zhukovskii, I. and Mokin, Z. (eds) (1920) Krasnaia Golgofa: sbornik, posviashchennyi pamiati tovarishchei, pogibshikh za raboche-krest’ianskoe delo [Red Calvary: a collection dedicated to the memory of comrades who died for the workers’ and peasants’ work]. Blagoveshchensk: Amurskaia Pravda.
57. Zinoviev, G. (1919) “Leon Tyshko (Iogikhes)” [Leon Tyshko (Iogikhes)], Kommunisticheskii Internatsional 5: 713–714.
58. Zritel’ (1924) “Gibel’ shestnadtsati” [The deaths of sixteen], Krasnaia Tatariia, June 18.
59. Zygmont, A. (2019) ““Dulce et decorum est”: fenomen muchenichestva v zapadnykh natsionalizmakh XVIII–XX vekov” [“Dulce et decorum est”: The Phenomenon of Martyrdom in Western Nationalisms of the Eighteenth to Twentieth Centuries], Sotsiologicheskoe obozrenie 18(3): 143–171.
Review
For citations:
Malysheva S. “They Will Fall in the Unearthly Grandeur”: The Early Soviet Cult of Martyrs of the Revolution. State, Religion and Church in Russia and Worldwide. 2022;40(1):58-88. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22394/2073-7203-2022-40-1-58-88
Views:
48
Email this article 