Catholic Liturgical Practices in Soviet Russia in the 1920s and 1930s: Canonical Norms and Anomalies

This paper examines changes in the liturgical and paraliturgical practices of Roman Catholics in Soviet Russia in the 1920s and 1930s. Nine documents from different archives outside Russia were first used to show changes made at the request of Russian Catholics. These documents deal with a number of disciplinary issues, such as the time for the celebration of Mass, observation of a natural fast before Mass, permission for lay people to bring Holy communion to the sick or imprisoned people. The Holy See readily relaxed canonical requirements. Consequently, at the turn of the 1920s and 1930s, the time for the celebration of Mass became variable, moving more often to the evening hours; the rules of a natural fast before Mass for clergy and laity were relaxed, which paved the way for regular communion at evening Masses; laity were given permission to bring Holy communion to those who could not personally hear the Mass; the practice of stipends for Mass became an instrument of financial support given by the Holy See to impoverished Catholic clergymen in critical situations. The main reason for these dramatic changes was the anti-religious policy of the Soviet government and the disruption of the traditional calendar. The fact of continuing contacts with the Vatican sheds light on those aspects of religious life in Soviet Russia that are not reflected in the official Soviet documentation.

1. Acta Apostolicae Sedis: Commentatium Officiale. Annus XII — Volumen XII; Annus XV — Volumen XV. Roma: Typis Poliglottis Vaticanis, 1920–1923.

2. Ayrinhac, H. (1928) Legislation on the Sacraments in the New Code of Canon Law: cc. 726–1011, 1144–1153. London.

3. Bachofen, A. (1925) A Commentary on the New Code of Canon Law. In 8 vols. Vol. IV. St. Louis; London.

4. Beglov, A. (2020) “Rossiiskaia Pravoslavnaia Tserkov’ v gody «Velikogo pereloma»: prikhodskii aspekt” [The Russian Orthodox Church during the ‘Great Turn’: the parish aspect], 1929: “Velikii perelom” i ego posledstviia: Materialy XII Mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii “Istoriia stalinizma”. Ekaterinburg, 26–28 sentiabria 2019 g. (Istoriia stalinizma. Debaty), pp. 369–381. Moscow.

5. Beglov, A., Tokareva, E. (2018) “Sudebnyi protsess nad katolicheskim dukhovenstvom 1923 g. v osveshchenii poslantsa Vatikana v Rossii” [The Trial of the Catholic Clergy in 1923 in the Coverage of the Vatican Envoy in Russia], Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel'nyi zhurnal «Istoriia»: 9(4(68)) [http://history.jes.su/s207987840002218-8-1, accessed on 20.05.2020].

6. Beglov, A.L. (2012) “Praktika prichashcheniia pravoslavnykh prikhozhan sovetskoi epokhi” [The Practice of Taking Communion Among Orthodox Parishioners in the Soviet Era], Gosudarstvo, religiia, Tserkov’ v Rossii i za rubezhom 3–4(30): 34–59.

7. Benedetto XIV. Inter Omnigenas, 23 [ http://www.vatican.va/content/benedictus-xiv/it/documents/enciclica--i-inter-omnigenas---i--2-febbraio-1744--il-pontefice-.html, accessed on 20.05.2020].

8. Boeckh, K. (2017) “Katolicheskie obshchiny v SSSR v 1918–1939 gg.” [Catholic communities in the USSR in 1918–1939], Vestnik tserkovnoi istorii 3/4(47/48): 332–352.

9. Boeckh, K. (2017) “Konfessionelle Netzwerke der Russland-Deutschen: Zur Verfolgung der Katholiken in der Sowjetunion (1917–1939)”, Historisches Jahrbuch 137: 268–303.

10. Chaplitskii, B., Osipova, I., ed. (2000) Kniga pamiati: Martirolog Katolicheskoi tserkvi v SSSR [Book of Remembrance: A Martyrology of the Catholic Church in the USSR]. Moscow.

11. Chiron, Y. (2018) Annibale Bugnini: Reformer of the Liturgy. Brooklyn.

12. Codex Iuris Canonici. Neo-Eboracum: P.J. Kennedy & Sons, 1918.

13. Dommarco, C. (2018) Il governo bolscevico e il Vaticano di fronte alla carestia degli anni Venti. Master in politica europea e internazionale. Milano, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore.

14. Dzwonkowski, D. (1997) Kościół katolicki w ZSRR 1917–1939. Zarys historii. Lublin.

15. Freeze, G. (1998) “Stalinist Assault on the Parish, 1929–1941”, in M. Hildermeier (ed.) Stalinismus vor dem Zweiten Weltkrieg; Neue Wege der Forschung, pp. 209–232. München.

16. Freeze, G. L. (2012) “«Vsia vlast’ prikhodam»: vozrozhdenie pravoslaviia v 1920-e gg.” [“All Power to the Parish!” An Orthodox Revival in 1920-s], Gosudarstvo, religiia, Tserkov’ v Rossii i za rubezhom 3/4(30): 86–105.

17. Grabovets, E. (2018) “Sviatoi Prestol i nemetskie katolicheskie sviashchenniki v Sovetskom Soiuze (1922–1938): naznacheniia, kontakty i kanaly sviazi v mezhdunarodnom kontekste” [The Holy See and Russian-German Catholic Priests in the Soviet Union (1922–1938): Nominations, Contacts and Communication Channels in the International Context], Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal «Istoriia». 9(4(68)) [http://history.jes.su/s207987840002207-6-1, accessed on 20.05.2020].

18. Herbermann, C. G. et al., ed. (1913) Catholic Encyclopedia: An International Work of Reference on the Constitution, Doctrine, Discipline, and History of the Catholic Church. In 17 vols. Vol. VII: Gregory — Infallibility. Vol. XIII: Revelation — Simon Stock. New York: The Encyclopedia Press.

19. Ignatiia, mon. (1999) Starchestvo na Rusi [Eldership in Rus’]. Moscow.

20. Kitsenko, N. (2012) “Ispoved’ v sovetskoe vremia” [‘Confession’ in Soviet times], Gosudarstvo, religiia, Tserkov’ v Rossii i za rubezhom 3–4(30): 10–33.

21. Kozlov-Strutinskii, S.G., Parfent’ev, P.A. (2014) Istoriia katolicheskoi tserkvi v Rossii [History of the Catholic Church in Russia]. SPb.

22. Krivova, N.A., ed. (2000) Sledstvennoe delo patriarkha Tikhona: Sb. dokumentov po materialam Tsentral’nogo arkhiva FSB RF [The investigation case of Patriarch Tikhon: Collection of documents from the Central Archive of FSB RF]. Moscow.

23. Lebedev, V.Iu. (2008) Religioznyi ritual zapadnogo khristianstva: kul’tura, traditsiia, semiotika (XVI–XX vv.) [Religious ritual of Western Christianity: Culture, Tradition, Semiotics (16th — 20th century)]. Tver’.

24. Litsenberger, O.A. (2001) Rimsko-Katolicheskaia Tserkov’ v Rossii. Istoriia i pravovoe polozhenie [The Roman Catholic Church in Russia: History and Legal Status]. Saratov.

25. Missale Romanum. Juxta Typicam Vaticanam. Roma, 2014.

26. Nedzeliuk, T.G. (2020) “Trudarmiia v vospominaniiakh sibirskikh nemtsev-katolikov” [Labour Army and memoirs of German Catholics in Siberia], Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal “Istoriia”. 11(7(93)) https://history.jes.su/s207987840010695-3-1/, accessed on 02.11.2020].

27. Osipova, I.I. (1996) “V iazvakh svoikh sokroi menia...”. Goneniia na katolicheskuiu tserkov’ v SSSR. Po materialam sledstvennykh i lagernykh del [Hide Me Within Thy Wounds: The Persecution of the Catholic Church in the USSR]. Moscow.

28. Petrakki, Dzh. (2003) “Papskaia missiia pomoshchi Rossii. 1921–1923 gg.” [The Papal Relief Mission to Russia, 1917–1923], Rossiia i Vatikan v kontse XIX — pervoi treti XX vv., pp. 185–259. Sankt-Peterburg.

29. Pokrovskii, N.N., Petrov, S.G., ed. (1997–1998) Arkhivy Kremlia. Politbiuro i tserkov’. 1922–1925 gg. Kn. 1–2 [Archives of the Kremlin. Politburo and the Church. 1922–1925. Book 1–2]. Moscow–Novosibirsk.

30. Reid, A. (2005) The Organic Development of the Liturgy. 2nd ed. San Francisco.

31. Rezmer, V. (2020) “Katolicheskaia tserkov’ v Sovetskoi Rossii (SSSR) v materialakh, khraniashchikhsia v Tsentral’nom voennom arkhive v Varshave” [Catholic Church in Soviet Russia (USSR) as described in materials kept inthe Central Military Archive in Warsaw], Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal «Istoriia» 11(7(93)) [https://history.jes.su/s207987840010696-4-1/, accessed on 02.11.2020].

32. Russo, O. (2013) Istoriia liturgicheskogo dvizheniia /Per. s fr. [History of the Liturgical Movement]. Kiev.

33. Sergii (Savel’ev), arkhim. (1998) Dalekii put’: Istoriia odnoi khristianskoi obshchiny [A long way: the story of a Christian community]. Moscow.

34. Shapoval, Iu.V. (2020) “Rol’ katolitsizma v sokhranenii etnicheskoi identichnosti deportirovannykh poliakov: keis Kazakhstana” [The role of Catholicism in preserving the ethnic identity of deported Poles: a case study of Kazakhstan], Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal “Istoriia” 11(7(93)) [https://history.jes.su/s207987840010706-5-1/, accessed on 02.11.2020].

35. Tokareva, E. (2017) “La distruzione dell’organizzazione ecclesiastica in Unione Sovietica”, La Chiesa cattolica in Unione Sovietica. Dalla Rivoluzione del 1917 alla perestrojka, pp. 79–89. Roma.

36. Tokareva, E.S. (2019) “Katoliki v sisteme gosudarstvenno-tserkovnykh otnoshenii v SSSR v 1920-e — 1930-e gg. XX veka: natsional’noe i mezhdunarodnoe izmerenie” [Catholics in the system of Church-State relations in the USSR in the 1920s–1930s: national and international dimension], Istoriia stalinizma. Konfessional’naia politika sovetskogo gosudarstva v 1920-1950-e gody, pp. 97–107. Moscow.

37. Tokareva, E.S. (2019) “Catholics in Russia facing the new authorities: 1917–1921”, Religiski-filozofiski raksti XXV, pp. 158–173. Riga.

38. Tolomeo, R. (2018) “Fond Komissii «Pro Russia» iz arkhiva Kongregatsii po delam Vostochnykh tserkvei kak istochnik materialov po izucheniiu otnoshenii mezhdu SSSR i Sviatym Prestolom vo vremia pontifikata Piia XI” [“Pro Russia” Commission Foundation from the Archive of the Congregation for Eastern Churches as a Source of Materials on the Study of Relations between the USSR and the Holy See during the Pontificate of Pius XI], Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel’nyi zhurnal “Istoriia” 9(4(68)) [http://history.jes.su/s207987840002205-4-1, accessed on 20.05.2020].

39. Vermeersch, A., Creusen, J. (1933) Epitome Juris Canonici cum commentariis. Bruxellis.

40. Walewander, E., ed. (1991) Polacy w Kościele Katolickim w ZSRR. Lublin.

41. Zadvornyi, V., Iudin, A. (1995) Istoriia Katolicheskoi Tserkvi v Rossii: Kratkii ocherk [History of the Catholic Church in Russia: A brief sketch]. Moscow.