2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
The Radical New Perspective on Paul, or Paul within Judaism: Origins, Influences, Ideas
ru
Original Article|VARIA
AbstractFull textReferencesFilesAuthorsAltmetrics
The article deals with reconstructions of Paul’s views on the Law, Jewish-Gentile relations, and redemption. These reconstructions were made by members of The Radical New Persepective on Paul / Paul within Judaism movement from the late 20th to the beginning of the 21st century. This movement has its origins in new perspectives on Second Temple Judaism. The radical new perspective on Paul argues the following characteristics in its construction of Paul: Paul remained fully Jewish even as a follower of Jesus; Paul remained Torah-observant; Paul writes to non-Jews and addresses his Gospel about a Jewish Messiah to Gentiles; Paul perceived humanity as consisting of two parts: Jews and non-Jews, even when united in the Messiah; Paul lived in a state of eschatological urgency with the end times and messianic age coming soon. Paul indeed sees himself as being involved in events that will lead to the salvation of the whole world. Paul’s Jewish ancestry and identity is a constitutive element of his self-understanding as apostle of Christ to the Gentiles. He is specifically occupied with the Gentile problem. Paul’s debates about Gentiles and circumcision can be understood as in-house Jewish debates about how to include Gentile outsiders in Jewish assemblies. Whenever Paul says anything negative about the Law, it is always about Gentile's relationship to the Law, not Jews’. Paul provides a way to maintain the particularity of his ethnic and religious identity without denying the ethnic and religious identity of others. Paul preaches a much more radical form of Judaism for Gentiles than diaspora synagogues ever requested, much less required. The scholars adhering to this perspective consider that Paul’s texts are not in the background of the Second Temple Judaism but as texts of the Second Temple Judaism.
Keywords: Biblical studies, early Christianity, New Testament, Paul, law, Torah, Israel, Second Temple Judaism
Волчков А. Раннехристианская община в античном полисе. М., 2019.
Левинская И. Деяния апостолов на фоне еврейской диаспоры. СПб., 2000.
Швейцер А. Мистика апостола Павла // Христос или Закон? Апостол Павел глазами новозаветной науки. М., 2006. С. 21-370.
Шолем Г. Основные течения в еврейской мистике. М., 2004.
Ястребов Г. Послания апостола Павла в современной науке // Павловы послания: комментированное издание. Москва, 2017. C. 751-770.
Barth, M. (1968) “Jews and Gentiles: The Social Character of Justification in Paul”, Journal of Ecumenical Studies 5: 241-267. Barth, M. (1974) Ephesians: Introduction, Translation, and Commentary on Chapters 1-3. New Haven.
Barth, M. (1979) “St. Paul - a Good Jew”, Horizons in Biblical Theology 1: 7-45.
Chauvire, Ch. (2005) “Peirce, Popper, Abduction, and the Idea of Logic of Discovery”, Semiotica 135: 209-221.
Collins, J. (2017) The Invention of Judaism: Torah and Jewish Identity from Deuteronomy to Paul. Oakland.
Donaldson, T. (2006) “Jewish Christianity, Israel’s Stumbling and the Sonderweg Reading of Paul”, Journal for the Study of the New Testament 29(1): 27-54.
Du Toit, Ph. (2017) “The Radical New Perspective on Paul, Messianic Judaism and their connection to Christian Zionism”, in HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies 73(3): 4603.
Eisenbaum, P. (2005) “Paul, Polemics, and the Problem of Essentialism”, Biblical Interpretation 13(3): 224-238.
Eisenbaum, P. (2009) Paul Was Not a Christian: The Original Message of a Misunderstood Apostle. New York.
Ehrensperger, K. (2020) “Die ›Paul within Judaism‹-Perspektive”, Evangelische Theologie 80(6): 455-64.
Fredriksen, P. (2010) “Judaizing the Nations: The Ritual Demands of Paul’s Gospel”, New Testament Studies 56: 232-52.
Fredriksen, P. (2014) “Paul’s Letter to the Romans, the Ten Commandments, and Pagan ‘Justification by Faith’”, Journal of Biblical Literature 133(4): 801-808.
Fredriksen, P. (2017) Paul: The Pagans’ Apostle. New Haven.
Gager, J. G. (2000) Reinventing Paul. Oxford.
Garroway, J. (2012) Paul’s Gentile-Jews: Neither Jew nor Gentile, but Both. New York. Garroway, J. (2019) “Paul: Within Judaism, Without Law”, in Lincicum, D. et al. (eds) Law and Lawlessness in Early Judaism and Christianity, pp. 49-66. Tübingen.
Gaston, Ll. (1987) Paul and the Torah. Vancouver.
Gathercole, S. (2002) Where Is Boasting? Early Jewish Soteriology and Paul’s Response in Romans 1-5. Michigan.
Grundmann, W. (1968) “The Teacher of Righteousness of Qumran and the Question of Justification by Faith in the Theology of the Apostle Paul”, in Murphy- O’Connor, J. (ed.) Paul and Qumran: Studies in New Testament Exegesis, pp. 85-114. Chicago.
Hedner-Zetterholm, K. (2015) “The question of assumptions: Torah observance in the first century”, in Nanos, M., Zetterholm, M. (eds) Paul within Judaism: Restoring the First-Century Context to the Apostle, pp. 79-103. Minneapolis.
Johnson Hodge, C. (2007) If Sons, Then Heirs: A Study of Kinship and Ethnicity in the Letters of Paul. Oxford.
Kaden, D. (2016) Matthew, Paul, and the Anthropology of Law. Tubingen. Langton, D. (2010) The Apostle Paul in the Jewish Imagination: A Study in Modern Jewish-Christian Relations. Cambridge.
Levine, L. (2005) The Ancient Synagogue: The First Thousand Years. New Haven. Mussner, F. (1984) Tractate on the Jews: The Significance of Judaism for Christian Faith. Philadelphia.
Nanos, M. (1996) The Mystery of Romans: The Jewish Context of Paul’s Letters. Minneapolis.
Nanos, M. (2012) “Paul’s Relationship to Torah in Light of His Strategy ‘to Become Everything to Everyone’ (1 Corinthians 9:19-23)”, in Pollefeyt, D., Bieringer, R. (eds) Paul and Judaism: Crosscurrents in Pauline Exegesis and the Study of Jewish Christian Relations, pp. 106-40. London.
Nanos, M. (2013) “Paul’s Polemic in Philippians 3 as Jewish-Subgroup Vilification of Local Non-Jewish Cultic and Philosophical Alternatives”, Journal for the Study of Paul and His Letters 3(1): 47-91.
Nanos, M. (2016) “How Could Paul Accuse Peter of ‘Living Ethné-ishly’ in Antioch (Gal 2:11-21) If Peter Was Eating according to Jewish Dietary Norms?”, Journal for the Study of Paul and His Letters 6(2): 199-223.
Nanos, M. (2017) “Reading the Antioch Incident (Gal 2:11-21) as a Subversive Banquet Narrative”, Journal for the Study of Paul and His Letters 7(1-2): 26-52.
Nanos, M. (2019) “Paul - Why Bother? A Jewish Perspective”, Svensk Teologisk Kvartalskrift 95(4): 271-87.
Nanos, M. (2021) “Re-Framing Paul’s Opposition to Erga Nomou as ‘Rites of a Custom’ for Proselyte Conversion Completed by the Synecdoche ‘Circumcision’”, Journal of The Jesus Movement in Its Jewish Setting 8: 75-115.
Novenson, M. (2009) “The Jewish Messiahs, the Pauline Christ, and the Gentile Question”, Journal of Biblical Literature 128(2): 357-373.
Novenson, M. (2019) “Whither the Paul within Judaism Schule?”, Journal of The Jesus Movement in Its Jewish Setting 9: 79-88.
Novenson, M. (2021) “What eschatological pilgrimage of the Gentiles?”, in Abel, F. (ed.) Israel and the Nations: Paul’s Gospel in the Context of Jewish Expectation, pp. 61-74. London.
Novenson, M. (2022) “Anti-Judaism and Philo-Judaism in Pauline Studies, Then and Now”, in Bakker, A. et al. (eds) Protestant Bible Scholarship: Antisemitism, Philosemitism and Anti-Judaism, pp. 106-124. Leiden.
Nyström, J. (2021) Reading Romans, Constructing Paul(s): A Conversation between Messianic Jews in Jerusalem and Paul within Judaism Scholars (PhD Thesis). Lund.
Osborne, R. (1964) “Did Paul go to Qumran?”, Canadian Journal of Theology X (1): 15-24.
Sandnes, K. O. (2018) Paul Perceived. An Interactionist Perspective on Paul and the Law. Tubingen.
Stendahl, K. (1976) Paul Among Jews and Gentiles and Other Essays. Philadelphia. Stendahl, K. (1995) Final Account: Paul’s Letter to the Romans. Minneapolis.
Stowers, S. (1994) A Rereading of Romans: Justice, Jews, and Gentiles. New Haven. Thiessen, M. (2016) Paul and the Gentile Problem. Oxford.
Thiessen, M. (2017) “Gentiles as impure animals in the writings of early Christ followers”, in Siegal, M., Grünstäudl, W., Thiessen, M. (eds) Perceiving the Other in Ancient Judaism and Early Christianity, pp. 19-32. Mohr Siebeck.
Thorsteinesson, R. (2005) Paul’s Interlocutor in Romans 2: Function and Identity in the Context of Ancient Epistolography. Stockholm.
Westerholm, S. (2004) Perspectives Old and New on Paul: The “Lutheran” Paul and His Critics. Michigan.
Zetterholm, M. (2015) “Paul within Judaism: The State of the Questions”, in Nanos, M., Zetterholm, M. (eds) Paul within Judaism: Restoring the First-Century Context to the Apostle, pp. 31-51. Minneapolis.
Zetterholm, M. (2016) “The Antioch Incident Revisited”, Journal for the Study of Paul and His Letters 6 (2): pp. 249-269.
© Article. Roman Popkov, 2024.